Company Benchmarking: Compare Companies to Make Informed Decisions

Company Benchmarking: Compare Companies to Make Informed Investment Choices

Every company has a constant goal of improvement and moving forward. However, it is not always easy to know what constitutes improvement and which way should the efforts be directed.

Just like ships in the open sea, firms need some sort of North Star to navigate the competitive business landscape toward success. In business, benchmarks provide such reference points for finding direction.

Business benchmarking is a widely applicable method that can help firms improve their current procedures, invest their assets better, and create data-based business strategies. Here we will look into different types of benchmarking and how anyone from big corporations to small businesses benefit from it.

What is benchmarking in business?

Company benchmarking is the measuring of a company’s performance levels, product quality, procedural efficiency, and other aspects that in one way or another define success. 

Benchmarking definition in business involves the identification of benchmarks against which the company or its features are to be measured. This basic model is applicable to different types of external and internal benchmarking.

Process benchmarking

This can be an entirely internal benchmarking approach, comparing the internal processes within a company. Internal benchmarking would allow the setting and implementation of a uniform standard for more efficient processes.

On the other hand, process benchmarking could use the processes in other firms as benchmarks to find the best industry practices. For example, external benchmarking could be used to identify the most efficient ways of digitizing processes within an industry.

Performance benchmarking

Company performance benchmarking compares the performance metrics of a firm against industry benchmarks. This type of company benchmarking focuses on key performance indicators (KPIs). 

Performance metrics, such as customer retention or net promoter score (NPS) help firms measure their progress toward their goals. However, setting meaningful and reasonable KPIs requires comparison with other businesses. Thus, a company that wants to understand its progress and opportunities looks not only at its own KPIs but at those of similar businesses.

Competitive benchmarking

Generally, companies can benchmark processes, products, customer satisfaction, and anything else of almost any other business, as long as they can expect to extract valuable insights.

Competitive benchmarking focuses on the firm’s competitors within their own industry. The goal of is to extract actionable insights that allow for improvements that could be immediately effective within the current competitive landscape. 

Strategic benchmarking

Rather than focusing on a particular process or product, strategic benchmarking looks at long-term strategies and continuous improvement. The aim is to understand masterful business strategies and get insight into how they can be implemented in your own company.

As strategic benchmarking is aspirational, and aimed at sustainable improvement, companies often analyze top industry performers. This includes not only top local competitors but also world-class organizations.

The key elements of company benchmarking

Companies of all sizes can conduct benchmarking for various purposes. The main elements are common to all benchmarking in business.

• The subject of benchmarking.The business aspect you want to internally or externally benchmark. It could be processes, products, performance, or anything else you can gather data on.
• Companies to use for benchmarking. The list of competitors or other firms you want to benchmark. In the case of internal benchmarking, this could be the list of your company’s branches and departments.
• Benchmarking plan.  The steps of your benchmarking process. It includes a description of what metrics you are going to track and how you intend to do it.
• Data collection. This is the key element of every strategic research. You need to identify data sources and gather data points relevant to the business metrics you want to track.
• Data analysis. Analyzing data to draw actionable business insights.
• Reporting and planning for improvement. Every successful business benchmarking is concluded with the implementation phase. Thus, it is crucial to present your findings to all key decision-makers in a convincing and understandable manner.

Many of these elements will also apply to investors benchmarking companies for stock value and potential comparison.

Company benchmarking best practices

There is no single recipe for benchmarking in business. Nevertheless, the following practices can increase the chances that you benefit from company benchmarking. 

Having clearly defined goals

You cannot do everything with one benchmarking process. And it can be a costly procedure, requiring extensive market research and allocation of resources. Thus, be specific about what you want to know, what type of benchmarking are you going to conduct, and what you expect to gain from it.

Limiting the number of companies

You might want to use a single competitor or a leading company for benchmarking. However, having just one business as your target might make getting all the necessary data challenging.

When using multiple companies, it is crucial to decide on them in advance and set limits to their number. Tracking too many companies at once might make it hard to stick to the same goal.

Thoroughly documenting your own processes

Benchmarking only makes sense if you have data on your own metrics to compare with that of others. Document all key aspects of the company’s product, strategy, and daily procedures. The earlier your firm implements data-driven practices the more you can expect to gain from business benchmarking.

Having a schedule

Benchmarking can be a costly procedure if you allow it to go out of proportion. Creating a schedule for every step of the benchmarking process will help everyone involved stay on the same page and focused on the goals.

Sticking to the timetable will limit the scope of your research, forcing you to track only the most relevant metrics. It will also allow you to extract actionable insights faster. The sooner you can use your knowledge and iterate on it, the more benefits will accumulate.

Using reliable data sources

Research insights are only as reliable as the sources used. Identify sources that provide data relevant to your goals immediately after setting them. Make sure that they are trustworthy, especially if you choose to buy data from third-party providers.

Enriching your data

Analyze the data you have to see if it provides the insights you hoped for. If it does not, you might still gain some valuable knowledge from the data points you have. 

Consider acquiring more data. If there is a reasonable expectation that data enrichment can provide a more robust analysis, it is more cost-effective to see it through. 

Continuous process

Company benchmarking should continue in cycles rather than reach a full stop. After investing in implementing the insights of initial benchmarking, new questions, and opportunities will arise. You will identify areas for further improvement that can lead to another cycle of benchmarking.

With every new cycle, you need to start from the beginning, reconsidering your goals and which firms you want to use for comparison.